Pastapadre Game of the Year
2018: NBA 2K19 (Press Row Podcast)
2017: MLB The Show 17/Madden NFL 18 (Press Row Podcast)
2016: MLB The Show 16 (Press Row Podcast)
2015: NBA 2K16 (Sporting News Awards -Â Podcast)
2014: NBA 2K15
2013: MLB 13: The Show
2012: FIFA 13
2011: FIFA 12
2010: NBA 2K11
2009: UFC 2009 Undisputed
2008: NCAA Football 09
2007: The BIGS
Community Game of the Year
2018: NBA 2K19
2017: MLB The Show 17
2016: MLB The Show 16
2015: NBA 2K16
2014: NBA 2K15
2013: MLB 13: The Show
2012: NBA 2K13
2011: FIFA 12
2010: NBA 2K11
2009: Madden NFL 10
Community Game of the 360/PS3/Wii Generation
NBA 2K11
Community Best New or Non-Yearly Game
2018: Super Mega Baseball 2
2017: The Golf Club 2
2016: EA Sports UFC 2
2015: Rocket League
2014: The Golf Club
2013: NO AWARD GIVEN
2012: UFC Undisputed 3
2011: Forza 4
2010: EA Sports MMA
Community Best Gameplay
2018: NBA 2K19
2017: MLB The Show 17
2016: MLB The Show 16
2015: NBA 2K16
2014: NBA 2K15
2013: NBA 2K14
2012: NBA 2K13
2011: FIFA 12
2010: NBA 2K11
Community Best Online Play
2018: Madden NFL 19
2017: Madden NFL 18
2016: Madden NFL 17
2015: Madden NFL 16
2014: Madden NFL 15
2013: Madden NFL 25
2012: Madden NFL 13
2011: Madden NFL 12
2010: NCAA Football 11
Community Best Presentation
2018: NBA 2K19
2017: NBA 2K18
2016: NBA 2K17
2015: NBA 2K16
2014: NBA 2K15
2013: NBA 2K14
2012: NBA 2K13
2011: NBA 2K12
2010: NBA 2K11
Community Best Franchise or Dynasty
2018: NBA 2K19
2017: NBA 2K18
2016: NBA 2K17
2015: NBA 2K16
2014: NBA 2K15
2013: Madden NFL 25
2012: Madden NFL 13
2011: Madden NFL 12
2010: NCAA Football 11
Community Best Story/Career Mode
2018: NBA 2K19 (MyCareer)
2017: Madden NFL 18 (Longshot)
2016: FIFA 17 (The Journey)
2015: NBA 2K16 (Livin Da’ Dream/MyCareer)
2014: NBA 2K15 (MyCareer)
2013: Road to the Show (MLB 13: The Show)
2012: MyCareer (NBA 2K13)
2011: Road to the Show (MLB 11: The Show)
2010: My Player/Creating a Legend (NBA 2K11)
Community Best New Feature
2018: Custom Draft Classes (Madden NFL 19)
2017: NHL Threes (NHL 18)
2016: Weekly Commentary Updates (Madden NFL 17)
2015: Year-to-Year Saves (MLB 15: The Show)
2014: Player Lock/Quick Counts (MLB 14: The Show)
2013: Postseason Mode (MLB 13: The Show)
2012: Connected Careers (Madden NFL 13)
2011: NBA’s Greatest (NBA 2K12)
2010: The Jordan Challenge (NBA 2K11)
Community Best Mobile
2018: NO AWARD GIVEN
2017: Motorsport Manager 2
2016: Photo Finish Horse Racing
2015: NO AWARD GIVEN
2014: WWE SuperCard
2013: FIFA 14
2012: FIFA 13
2011: NBA Jam
2010: Madden NFL 11
Best Racing Game
2018: F1 2018
2017: F1 2017
2016: Forza Horizon 3
Best Post-Release Support
2018: Madden NFL 19
2017: Madden NFL 18
2016: Madden NFL 17
2015: Madden NFL 16
2014: EA Sports UFC
Best Team-Building Mode
2018: Out of the Park Baseball 19 (Perfect Team)
2017: MLB The Show 17 (Diamond Dynasty)
2016: MLB The Show 16 (Diamond Dynasty)
2015: MLB 15: The Show (Diamond Dynasty)