Late Season Check on Current QB Ratings in Madden NFL 13
by 
With the regular season nearing it’s end, and having twice looked at them before, there is another opportunity to evaluate where quarterbacks stand in Madden NFL 13 compared to their performance for the year. How have things developed in terms of their ratings as more data has been entered into consideration? They appear to now be more in line with their actual production – though players that began higher or lower have faced those prejudices along the way.
Through week 15 in evaluating starting QBs with sufficient game action the average output is 2970 yards, 61% completions, 19 touchdown passes, 14 interceptions, and a 51.6 ESPN Total QBR. That average player is then rated 83 overall right now in Madden NFL 13.Â
|
Name |
 (Yards-Comp%-TD-INT-TQBR) |
Rating |
Status |
| Tom Brady | 4276-63%-30TD-6INT-78.8QBR | 99 | —– |
| Peyton Manning | 4016-68%-31TD-10INT-81.5QBR | 97 | Slightly Underrated |
| Aaron Rodgers | 3588-67%-32TD-8INT-71.9QBR | 96 | —– |
| Eli Manning | 3590-60%-20TD-15INT-66.0QBR | 96 | Overrated |
| Ben Roethlisberger | 2911-64%-22TD-6INT-68.3QBR | 95 | Slightly Overrated |
| Drew Brees | 4335-62%-36TD-18INT-64.4QBR | 94 | Slightly Overrated |
| Matt Ryan | 4202-68%-27TD-14INT-74.6QBR | 93 | —– |
| Cam Newton | 3451-58%-18TD-10INT-54.0QBR | 90 | Vastly Overrated |
| Tony Romo | 4269-67%-22TD-16INT-63.8QBR | 89 | —– |
| Matt Schaub | 3555-65%-22TD-10INT-66.0QBR | 89 | —– |
| Robert Griffin III | 2902-66%-18TD-4INT-71.3QBR | 89 | Slightly Underrated |
| Matthew Stafford | 4252-59%-17TD-15INT-58.1QBR | 88 | Slightly Overrated |
| Joe Flacco | 3474-59%-20TD-10INT-44.9QBR | 88 | Vastly Overrated |
| Alex Smith | 1731-70%-13TD-5INT-69.8QBR | 88 | Now a backup |
| Jay Cutler | 2630-60%-17TD-14INT-49.5QBR | 87 | Overrated |
| Philip Rivers | 3290-64%-22TD-15INT-38.0QBR | 86 | Vastly Overrated |
| Andrew Luck | 3978-55%-20TD-18INT-65.5QBR | 86 | —– |
| Andy Dalton | 3316-63%-26TD-14INT-53.0QBR | 86 | —– |
| Russell Wilson | 2697-63%-21TD-9INT-68.7QBR | 85 | Underrated |
| Michael Vick | 2165-58%-11TD-9INT-47.5QBR | 85 | Backup/Overrated |
| Josh Freeman | 3471-55%-25TD-12INT-56.9QBR | 85 | —– |
| Carson Palmer | 3987-61%-22TD-14INT-44.6QBR | 84 | Slightly Overrated |
| Sam Bradford | 3254-60%-18TD-11INT-48.8QBR | 84 | Slightly Overrated |
| Matt Hasselbeck | 1367-62%-7TD-5INT-48.5QBR | 81 | Backup |
| Colin Kaepernick | 1289-66%-7TD-2INT-79.5QBR | 80 | Underrated (but early) |
| Ryan Fitzpatrick | 2935-62%-22TD-15INT-45.1QBR | 80 | —– |
| Jake Locker | 1884-58%-9TD-9INT-53.9QBR | 79 | Slightly Underrated |
| Kevin Kolb | 1169-59%-8TD-3INT-38.0QBR | 78 | IR |
| Ryan Tannehill | 2929-59%-10TD-12INT-52.5QBR | 77 | Slightly Underrated |
| Jason Campbell | 265-63%-2TD-2INT-23.5QBR | 77 | Overrated |
| Brandon Weeden | 3281-57%-14TD-17INT-26.1QBR | 76 | Overrated |
| Blaine Gabbert | 1662-58%-9TD-6INT-40.9QBR | 75 | IR |
| Mark Sanchez | 2678-55%-13TD-17INT-25.0QBR | 75 | Overrated |
| Chad Henne | 1438-52%-8TD-5INT-26.3QBR | 75 | Overrated |
| Christian Ponder | 2527-63%-14TD-12INT-45.0QBR | 74 | Slightly Underrated |
| Matt Cassel | 1796-58%-6TD-12INT-36.5QBR | 74 | Backup |
| Nick Foles | 1356-59%-5TD-4INT-48.1QBR | 73 | Slightly Underrated |
| Kirk Cousins | 466-69%-4TD-3INT-72.7QBR | 73 | Underrated (early) |
| Brady Quinn | 930-60%-2TD-6INT-38.9QBR | 71 | —– |
| John Skelton | 1132-54%-2TD-9INT-13.9QBR | 69 | Overrated |
| Ryan Lindley | 611-51%-0TD-6INT-8.1QBR | 63 | —– |